S.Students returning to class in the town of the Ozarks this fall
Cassville , Missouri, you may be looking better than usual. That’s because the local school board has reinstated corporal punishment, otherwise known as paddling, to discipline bad behavior.
spanking
policy
It’s not like the old days of law and order in the classroom. Parents and guardians must sign a consent agreement for the child to paddle “if other discipline measures fail”, including detention or suspension. You can also opt out at any time, regardless of what your child has done to justify a body search.
Cassville will also keep the bang out of sight of other children and will include a second adult staff member as a witness. Hits in the face or head were not allowed and there was no mention of whether video recordings would be kept. Individual Principals have discretion over when and to whom to apply the Hip Penalty option. The Board Policy Manual states: Confinement of a student in accordance with the district’s policy on student isolation and restraint is not a violation of this policy. ”
The directive has unsurprisingly sparked a wave of outrage on social media and some protests from some educators. Some of them called the body treatment “a highly inappropriate and ineffective practice.” But the superintendent of her 1,900-student district in Cassville has responded to concerns from parents, employees and students that misbehavior at school has gotten out of hand, and the move to liberalize the rod has been made. said.
Missouri has a 1977 Supreme Court ruling (
Ingraham vs Wright
) states that spanking in schools does not violate the Eighth Amendment prohibition against cruel and unusual punishment unless it is “unreasonable” or “excessive.”from recent
federal data
Approximately 4,000 schools nationwide reported using some form of corporal punishment when available.
I vividly remember and feel the pain of paddling in 1962 with Miss McDonald’s stern hand, the principal of the elementary school. After a severe blizzard, orders were issued to students not to walk across the ballfield, perhaps for fear that kindergarteners might get lost adrift. A sophomore couple and I were forced out for defying the ban. We were paraded in front of the class and instructed to crouch down. Now that her Miss M with the bun hair is blowing deeply into her nose just before hitting her twice on my ass with a board that grips the board as tightly as Federer’s forehand I can hear it though. Her paddle had a leather wrist strap to indicate how often it was used.
Several prominent medical and behavioral groups including
American Psychological Association
has long opposed spanking in schools, arguing that, aside from the risk of injury, such punishment has been disproportionately inflicted on minority children. There are also concerns that hitting a child, even in a controlled manner, provokes more rebellion and aggression.
But so long as it’s deployed fairly and restraint, the mere threat of ritual paddling can keep confused students unresponsive to other types of instructions in check. I don’t think it’s a mistake to remove punishment from the classroom. I experienced extreme humiliation from being flogged. By isolating actors in spanking scenarios, Cassville loses the powerful effect of public peer shaming that could be a real deterrent to future misconduct, or at least breaking the rules.
A long time ago, you may have scored bravery points with your mates. And I continued to instigate mischief, sometimes going to the edge of school etiquette. Hopefully it will prevent some of the Cassville idiots from doing the same if they lick it in private.
Allan Ripp runs a public relations firm in New York.
